Sticking to a diet can be difficult because day after day of counting every calorie, measuring every bite and pretending you don’t want the fries can get old fast.
You might be able to do it for a few days or even a few weeks, but then real life happens. A birthday dinner, a stressful workday, a slice of cake that is absolutely calling your name.
That is part of the reason alternate-day fasting has gotten so much attention. The idea is simple: eat very little one day, then eat more normally the next day.
Alternate-day fasting can be a useful weight-loss strategy for some people, and it may offer certain metabolic benefits. But, like most diet trends, it is not magic, and it is not the right fit for everyone.
Alternate-day fasting is a form of intermittent fasting where you alternate between fasting days and eating days. Traditionally, fasting days may involve no calories, but many modern versions allow about 500 calories, which is often called “modified” alternate-day fasting.
Older summaries of the diet, including one from WebMD writer Siobhan Harris shared through this alternate-day fasting overview, describe it as eating what you want one day, then limiting intake the next day. That is still the basic idea, but I would be careful with the phrase “eat whatever you want.”
Can you eat more freely on non-fasting days? Yes.
Does that mean the non-fasting day should become an all-day field trip through pizza, doughnuts and the pantry? Probably not, unless you enjoy canceling out your own efforts.
Most research on alternate-day fasting still depends on an overall calorie deficit. In other words, the fasting days need to reduce your weekly calorie intake enough to matter.
Research does suggest that alternate-day fasting can lead to weight loss, especially in the short term. A study published in Obesity looked at alternate-day fasting in adults with obesity and found that participants lost weight over the study period while following the fasting routine.
In that study, available through the National Library of Medicine, people following alternate-day fasting lost an average of about 18 pounds after eight weeks. Those following a standard calorie-restricted diet lost nearly 16 pounds, which suggests alternate-day fasting can be about as effective as traditional calorie restriction.
That is encouraging, but the difference between the two approaches was not exactly earth-shattering. It is more like, “this may work for some people,” not “throw away every other diet strategy immediately.”
A 2015 review in Nutrition Reviews also found that alternate-day fasting was associated with weight loss in studies lasting three to 12 weeks. In that review of alternate-day fasting studies, participants generally lost about 3% to 7% of their body weight.
Alternate-day fasting can help with weight loss, but the biggest question is whether you can actually stick with it.
This is where things get interesting. Alternate-day fasting may sound more exciting than a standard low-calorie diet, but that does not automatically mean it works better.
A well-known randomized clinical trial published in JAMA Internal Medicine compared alternate-day fasting with daily calorie restriction and a control group over one year. The study found that alternate-day fasting did not produce better weight loss or better weight maintenance than daily calorie restriction.
Also worth noting: the alternate-day fasting group had a higher dropout rate. That doesn’t surprise me, because eating very little every other day can feel simple in theory and very annoying by Wednesday.
A 2016 report in Obesity Science & Practice reviewed multiple studies and found that intermittent fasting approaches, including alternate-day fasting, produced weight loss results that were generally similar to continuous calorie restriction. The same review on intermittent versus daily calorie restriction did suggest fasting plans may help some people lose body fat, but overall, the results were not dramatically different.
In plain English: alternate-day fasting can work. But it does not appear to be some secret shortcut that beats every other weight-loss method.
Many people worry that fasting will “wreck” their metabolism. That is a common fear, and thankfully, short-term research does not really support that in the way social media sometimes claims.
In a small study published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, participants fasted every other day for 22 days. The study results showed that resting metabolic rate did not significantly decrease during the fasting period.
That said, it was a small and short study. As a nutrition professional, I always prefer larger studies, longer follow-up and real-life conditions, because humans are not lab robots who happily follow rules forever.
Short-term alternate-day fasting does not appear to slow metabolism in a major way, but long-term success still depends on food quality, consistency and whether the plan feels livable.
Alternate-day fasting may improve more than just the number on the scale. Some research suggests it can help with markers related to heart health, insulin sensitivity, inflammation and blood lipids.
A review published in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that some alternate-day fasting studies showed improvements in risk factors for heart disease and diabetes. As noted in the review on intermittent fasting and health outcomes, however, more research is needed before we can make big, sweeping claims.
Reports from the National Institute on Aging also indicate that intermittent fasting may have metabolic benefits, but many of the strongest findings still come from animal studies or shorter human trials. Translation: promising, but not a free pass to crown it the perfect diet.
Another thing to remember is that weight loss itself can improve blood pressure, cholesterol and blood sugar levels. The benefit may not be unique to fasting; it may simply be the result of reducing overall calorie intake and losing excess body fat.
There are different ways to do alternate-day fasting. Some plans allow only zero-calorie beverages on fasting days, such as water, black coffee and unsweetened tea.
Other versions allow about 500 calories, usually from foods that provide some protein, fiber and volume. Think eggs, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, vegetables, soup, fruit, beans, fish or lean poultry.
Personally, I would rather someone eat a small, balanced meal on a fasting day than white-knuckle their way through hunger and then become a human vacuum cleaner the next morning. But that is also why I prefer sustainable strategies over “how miserable can we make this?” diet plans.
On non-fasting days, the goal should be normal, satisfying eating. That means plenty of fruits and vegetables, lean proteins, whole grains, beans, nuts, seeds and healthy fats.
Yes, you can include foods you love. No, the plan works better when every eating day does not turn into a “because I fasted yesterday” festival.
Alternate-day fasting is not a good fit for everyone. People who are pregnant or breastfeeding, have a history of an eating disorder, are underweight, are still growing, or have certain medical conditions should avoid fasting unless specifically guided by a qualified health care professional.
Those who take medications for diabetes, blood pressure or other conditions should also talk with their doctor before trying it. Fasting can affect blood sugar, hydration, blood pressure and medication timing, and that is not something to just wing.
As noted by the Harvard Health Publishing, intermittent fasting may be helpful for some people, but it should still be approached thoughtfully. I would add that any plan that makes you feel dizzy, overly fatigued, obsessed with food or out of control around eating is probably not your plan.
Alternate-day fasting can help some people lose weight, and it may improve certain markers of metabolic health. Current research suggests it works mostly because it helps reduce overall calorie intake, not because it has some magical fat-burning superpower.
The potential downside is that it can be hard to stick with. Eating very little every other day may not be realistic for many people, especially if you have a busy schedule, family meals, workouts or just a basic desire to not be hungry half the week.
Alternate-day fasting may be worth trying if it feels manageable, but it is not necessary for weight loss or better health.
A more successful long-term approach might be choosing a pattern you can actually live with. For some, that may be alternate-day fasting; for others, it may be a Mediterranean-style diet, a higher-protein meal plan, simple portion control or just eating more whole foods and fewer ultra-processed foods.
At the end of the day, the best plan is the one that helps you eat well, enjoy your life and stay consistent without feeling punished by your own kitchen.
To provide better user experience and correct display of content, this site uses cookies. By continuing to use our site or providing information you are agreeing to our Privacy & Cookie Policy.