What are the Substitutes for Cashew Butter? (Best Alternatives!)

Cashew butter has a lot of the same applications as peanut butter. Spreading cashew butter on toast, sandwiches, or crackers is a great way to enjoy this versatile spread.

Cashew butter contains many beneficial nutrients like healthy fats, protein, vitamins, and minerals.

In addition to being pricey and hard to get, cashew butter is also a rarity.

You may need to find a suitable alternative to ensure you are never short of it. Moreover, if you have an allergy to cashews, you might not find a substitute that lets you enjoy the taste without putting you at risk.


Flavor Profile of Cashew Butter

The flavor of roasted cashew butter is somewhat nutty and slightly sweet.

The raw variety has a more subdued flavor because it lacks the nuttiness of the cooked form. The two types of cashew butter are quite similar in texture to peanut butter, both smooth and creamy.


Best Alternatives for Cashew Butter

You can use the following alternatives for cashew butter:


1. Peanut Butter

You can swap the cashew butter in your recipe for some peanut butter. It can be found in most grocery stores for a low price and tastes similar to cashew butter.

Peanut butter is the most versatile of all the butter varieties. It’s adaptable and interchangeable with just about any other formulation. Because of this quality, it is the most popular spread available in the market.

Almost any dish that calls for cashew butter can be made with peanut butter, thanks to its similar texture and flavor profile. Like cashew butter, peanut butter is a great way to get your daily dose of vitamins E, B, and more.

Furthermore, peanut butter has more beneficial proteins than cashew butter.

Furthermore, cashew butter is much harder to come by than peanut butter. You can find it quickly, it’s cheaper, and it’s all set up for you to use.

People often have adverse responses to peanut butter, which is the only real drawback. Avoid this one if you have a peanut allergy or lactose intolerance.


2. Almond Butter

If you’re out of cashew butter, try almond butter instead.

Similar in texture and taste to cashew butter, it is rich and velvety.

Most recipes that call for cashew butter can be made with almond butter.


3. Sunflower Seed Butter

You can also use sunflower seed butter as a tasty alternative to cashew butter. Similar in texture and taste to cashew butter, it is rich and velvety.

Butter made from sunflower seeds can be used in place of cashew butter in most dishes. It is a good alternative for those who have nut allergies.

The nutty flavor of sunflower butter, made from crushed and roasted sunflower seeds, is just the right amount of mild and robust. It has a noticeable flavor that doesn’t overshadow the dish.

Since it has a distinct flavor, sunflower butter is a great addition to any meal. It’s easy to find and doesn’t alter the taste of your food.

Therefore, it benefits you on both ends.


4. Coconut Butter

As an alternative to cashew butter, coconut butter is a delicious spread.

It tastes like cashew butter and has a creamy texture to match. You can use coconut butter to replace cashew butter.


5. Pine Nut Paste

You can swap the cashew butter in your favorite recipes for some pine nut paste with a similar flavor and texture. The same can be said if you’re trying to find a vegan alternative to cashew butter.


6. Soy Nut Butter

Many don’t know this, but soy nut butter can be used as a viable substitute for cashew butter. As the name suggests, this butter is made from roasted soybeans, salt, and oil.

Eating soy nut butter is a healthy choice because soy nuts provide protein. Sugar and palm oil are taste enhancers that some manufacturers may sneak into their recipes.

Many dishes benefit from the soy nut butter’s velvety texture.

However, the buttery taste can put off others who want something more subtle. Hence, sugar is used in several products once more. Add additional jam for extra taste if you like.

A lot of nutrition is packed into a serving of soy nut butter.

You can obtain adequate calories, good fats, and a gram of unsaturated fat from a single tablespoon. You can also get a few grams of protein.

Soy nut butter is a good source of minerals like calcium and iron (1).

Given that soybeans are used in producing soy nut butter, the likelihood of an allergic reaction to nuts is low. With a mild taste, it can complement a wide range of ingredients.

Soy nut butter’s only real drawback is that it can be hard to find. It’s not easy to come by, but if you can find it, it’s a great alternative.


7. Tahini

Tahini can be used as a suitable substitute for cashew butter.

It is produced from ground sesame seeds and resembles cashew butter in terms of texture. It’s a healthy choice because it has a lot of protein and good fats (2).


8. Toasted Apple Spread

You can swap cashew butter in your recipe for some apple butter.

It tastes a lot like cashew butter, which means it’s sweet.

Apple butter can be substituted for cashew butter in nearly all cases.


9. Avocado

For those allergic to cashews, avocado is a fantastic substitute for cashew butter.

Most recipes that call for cashew butter can be made with avocado; mash it up until you have the right consistency. The healthful fats in it are another bonus.


10. Walnut Butter

Walnut butter is a tasty alternative to cashew butter for those who are allergic to cashews or prefer the flavor of walnuts.

Both types of butter have a similar flavor and texture, but there are important distinctions to remember when deciding which to use.

To begin, walnuts are mildly sweeter than cashews, which means you may get away with using less sugar in your dish.

Because it is thinner than cashew butter, walnut butter demands different cooking conditions.

Walnut butter is a wonderful alternative to cashew butter that can be used in many of the same recipes without causing allergic reactions.

It’s a good source of omega-3 fatty acids and helps decrease cholesterol, so it might be helpful for your heart, just like cashew butter (3).

Because of its bitter taste, walnut butter isn’t a perfect replacement for cashew butter in many applications. Also, it’s not the cheapest nut butter and might be hard to come by.


11. Macadamia Nut Butter

Regarding flavor, macadamia nut butter is one of the most similar to cashew butter.

Macadamia nut butter, like macadamia nuts, has a mild, nutty flavor with nearly no other discernible notes.

Calcium content is high in this butter. Moreover, you can also find fat and protein content that can be helpful for your health (4).


Health Benefits

Cashew butter has several positive effects on health. Some of them are as follows (5,6):

  • Cashew butter has gained a lot of popularity due to its many nutrients, which have been shown to have positive health effects.
  • Because it contains B vitamins like thiamin, pyridoxine, and folate, cashew butter can give you some of the vitamins you need daily.
  • Cashews stand out for having one of the highest magnesium levels of any tree nut.
  • Cashew butter is a great source of protein and healthy fats and contains iron and potassium.
  • Cashew butter has lower fat content than other nut kinds of butter, but it’s still a wonderful source of healthy monounsaturated fats.
  • Cashew butter is an excellent source of protein and other amino acids. Cashew butter provides a substantial portion of the protein you need per day.
  • Consuming nut butter, such as cashew butter, can help lower your chance of developing gallstones.
  • Due to its high magnesium and mineral content, cashew butter can be used to treat osteoporosis and other bone diseases.
  • If you’re trying to avoid developing diabetes, you might want to try using cashew butter as an alternative to traditional nut butter.

Check also:

The Best Substitutes for Chuck Roast


Health Disquiets

Cashew butter can have a high sodium level, causing or exacerbating hypertension and other related health problems (5,6). The amount of fat in cashew butter is little, yet it is still there.

Cashew butter contains some saturated fat, which is bad for you.

Consuming unhealthy fats can lead to a rise in blood cholesterol, leading to heart disease.


Regular Applications

Cashew butter, like peanut butter, is best used as a spread over toast, bagels, or crackers.

It’s also a great vegan protein source that works well in porridge and smoothies. It can be used in place of peanut butter in satay sauce and salad dressings.

It’s great in muffins, cookies, and other baked products.



Can you compare cashew butter to peanut butter?

The answer is that cashew butter is comparable to peanut butter. Both are rich and satisfying and taste somewhat nutty. You can substitute cashew butter for peanut butter in any dish that calls for it.


Is it possible to substitute almond butter for cashew butter?

Similar in texture and taste to cashew butter, it is rich and velvety. Most recipes for cashew butter can be made with almond butter instead.


Can you use Sunflower butter as an alternative to cashew butter?

A good alternative to cashew butter is sunflower butter. Similar in texture and taste to cashew butter, it is rich and velvety. It can be used in place of cashew butter in most dishes.