Yogurt can absolutely be a nutritious addition to a healthy diet. It can help you meet your calcium needs, add protein to meals and snacks, and, depending on the type you choose, provide live cultures that may support gut health.
But walk down the yogurt aisle and it can feel like you need a nutrition degree, a calculator and maybe a snack just to get through it. There are Greek yogurts, regular yogurts, drinkable yogurts, kid yogurts, high-protein yogurts, plant-based yogurts and yogurts that taste suspiciously close to dessert.
For all those yogurt lovers, I have some label-reading help to share. And yes, plain yogurt usually gives you the most nutrition for the least added sugar, but what if you just don’t like it?
Anyway, let’s talk about how to pick a healthier yogurt without making this more complicated than it needs to be.
Nutrition Facts and Ingredients List
Just like with most packaged foods, the shorter and more recognizable the ingredient list, the better. Ideally, yogurt should have milk and live active cultures, and then maybe fruit, vanilla or a small amount of sweetener if it is flavored.
What always throws me off is when a yogurt starts looking less like yogurt and more like a science project. Multiple sweeteners, gums, colors, dessert toppings and candy mix-ins usually mean you are moving away from an everyday nutritious choice and more toward a treat.
Calories depend on the type of yogurt, the serving size and whether it is nonfat, low-fat, whole milk, Greek or plant-based. For a single-serve 5- to 6-ounce cup, a reasonable range is usually about 80 to 180 calories, though some higher-protein or whole milk varieties may be a little higher.
That is not automatically a bad thing. A yogurt with a few more calories, more protein and better staying power can be a much better choice than a low-calorie one that leaves you digging through the pantry 20 minutes later.
For calcium, check the % Daily Value on the Nutrition Facts label. As noted by the FDA’s Nutrition Facts label guidance, 20% Daily Value or more is considered high, and yogurt can be a great way to get there.
Dairy foods, including yogurt, are also included in the USDA MyPlate dairy group because they provide nutrients such as calcium, protein, vitamin D and potassium. Of course, that assumes you are choosing a yogurt that has not been turned into candy with a spoon.
Sugar
This one is still tricky, but thankfully it is less tricky than it used to be. The updated Nutrition Facts label now separates “Total Sugars” from “Added Sugars,” which is exactly what we needed years ago.
All dairy yogurt contains some naturally occurring sugar because milk contains lactose. That means plain yogurt will still show sugar on the label, even when no sugar has been added.
The number I care about most is added sugar. For an everyday yogurt, I like to see 0 grams of added sugar in plain yogurt and, ideally, about 7 grams or less of added sugar in flavored yogurt.
That does not mean a yogurt with more sugar can never be eaten. It just means I would treat it more like dessert, and there is nothing wrong with calling dessert what it is.
The current Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend limiting added sugars to less than 10% of calories per day. That can add up quickly when breakfast is sweetened yogurt, granola, sweetened coffee and maybe a “healthy” muffin that is basically cake in office clothing.
Another little trick: buy plain yogurt and add your own fruit, cinnamon, vanilla extract, nuts, seeds or a small drizzle of honey. You will usually end up with less added sugar than many pre-sweetened cups, and it tastes much better than pretending you enjoy sour plain yogurt when you really don’t.
Protein
Protein is one of the biggest differences between regular and Greek yogurt. Regular yogurt may have around 5 to 8 grams of protein per serving, while Greek yogurt often has 12 to 18 grams, depending on the brand and serving size.
That higher protein can make Greek yogurt more filling, which is why I often recommend it for breakfast or snacks. It also works great as a swap for sour cream or mayo in some recipes, although please do not ask it to replace everything delicious in your life.
Skyr, which is an Icelandic-style cultured dairy product, is another high-protein option that is now easier to find in many grocery stores. It tends to be thick like Greek yogurt and can be a nice choice for those who want more protein without a lot of added sugar.
Plant-based yogurts can be a good option too, especially for those who avoid dairy, but read the label carefully. Many almond, coconut and oat-based yogurts are quite low in protein unless they are made with soy, pea protein or added protein.
That does not make plant-based yogurt “bad,” but it may change how you use it. A coconut yogurt with 1 gram of protein may be tasty with berries, but it is not going to keep you satisfied the same way a Greek yogurt with 15 grams of protein might.
Live Active Cultures
The best yogurt choices will contain live and active cultures. These are the bacteria used to ferment milk into yogurt, and some strains may offer digestive and other health benefits.
Look for wording such as “live and active cultures,” “living yogurt cultures” or the Live & Active Culture seal. Common cultures include Lactobacillus bulgaricus, Streptococcus thermophilus, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Bifidobacterium and Lactobacillus casei.
Important to note, not all yogurts have the same probiotic benefits. As the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health notes about probiotics, benefits depend on the specific strain, dose and health condition being studied.
In other words, yogurt can be great for gut health, but it is not magic. I know, rude.
Also, heat-treated yogurts may not contain live cultures by the time you eat them. That is why the wording on the container matters more than the pretty front label that says things like “crafted,” “wholesome” or “for your wellness journey.”
Fat Content
For years, everyone was told to choose fat-free everything. Then full-fat dairy made a comeback, and now the yogurt aisle has decided to give us every possible fat percentage under the sun.
Here is where I land: choose the yogurt you enjoy and that fits your overall diet. Nonfat and low-fat yogurts can be excellent choices, especially if you are watching saturated fat intake, but whole milk yogurt can also fit into a healthy eating pattern in the right portions.
The Dietary Guidelines still recommend limiting saturated fat to less than 10% of calories per day. The American Heart Association’s saturated fat guidance also suggests replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats when possible for heart health.
That does not mean whole milk yogurt is “bad.” It does mean you may want to pay attention to portion size and what else you are eating throughout the day.
Personally, I would rather someone choose a small whole milk yogurt with berries and nuts than a fat-free yogurt loaded with added sugars that leaves them hungry. It’s all about the trade-offs.
Artificial Sweeteners
This is a controversial topic, and people tend to have very strong feelings about it. Some will not touch artificial sweeteners, while others use them all day long in coffee, soda, yogurt, protein bars and everything in between.
As a dietitian, I think low- and no-calorie sweeteners can have a place, especially for people trying to reduce added sugar. But I am not a fan of making every single sweet-tasting food in your diet artificially sweetened.
Sweeteners such as sucralose, aspartame, acesulfame potassium, monk fruit and stevia are used in many light yogurts. The FDA has reviewed several high-intensity sweeteners for use in foods, but moderation still matters.
My suggestion is this: if a light yogurt helps you enjoy yogurt and manage added sugar, that can be okay. But if you eat yogurt often, I would rotate in plain or lower-sugar options too.
I also recommend paying attention to taste and digestion. Some people do just fine with these sweeteners, while others notice bloating, cravings or just a weird aftertaste that ruins the whole yogurt experience.
Organic vs. Non-Organic
Organic yogurt means the milk comes from cows raised according to organic standards, including organic feed and restrictions on antibiotics and synthetic hormones. It does not automatically mean the yogurt is lower in sugar, higher in protein or nutritionally perfect.
That last part matters. I have seen organic yogurts with plenty of added sugar, and I have seen non-organic yogurts with simple ingredients and great nutrition.
My suggestion? Go organic with the foods you eat most often if it matters to you and fits your budget.
I eat a lot of yogurt, so organic is something I may choose when it is available and not wildly expensive. But the healthiest yogurt for you is still the one with a good ingredient list, reasonable added sugar and enough protein to make it worth eating.
What About Lactose-Free Yogurt?
Lactose-free yogurt can be a great choice for people who are lactose intolerant but still want dairy yogurt. It usually contains the same basic nutrients as regular yogurt, but the lactose has been broken down to make it easier to digest.
Greek yogurt may also be tolerated better by some people with lactose intolerance because some of the lactose is strained out with the whey. However, tolerance varies, so this is one of those “know your own body” situations.
What About Kids’ Yogurts?
Kids’ yogurts can be convenient, but some are surprisingly high in added sugar for such tiny containers. The cartoons on the package may be cute, but they do not get a free pass from the Nutrition Facts label.
Look for lower added sugar, some protein and calcium, and try not to get too distracted by the tubes, pouches, sprinkles and neon colors. I know, the marketing department worked very hard on those.
What to Look for in a Healthy Yogurt
Here is my quick yogurt checklist:
- Plain or lower added sugar: ideally 0 grams added sugar for plain yogurt and around 7 grams or less for flavored yogurt.
- Good protein: aim for at least 5 grams per serving, or 10 grams or more if you want it to be more filling.
- Calcium: look for a meaningful % Daily Value, preferably around 15% to 20% or more.
- Live active cultures: especially if you are choosing yogurt for gut-health benefits.
- Simple ingredients: milk, cultures and maybe fruit or a small amount of sweetener.
- Fat level that fits your diet: nonfat, low-fat and whole milk can all work depending on your needs and portions.
- Flavor you actually enjoy: because healthy food you hate is not a long-term plan.
Common Yogurt Brands Found at Your Regular Grocer
*These were originally suggested for review by Healthy Apron fans. Formulas and ingredients change often, so always check the label in your own store.
- Stonyfield Organic Yogurt: Still a solid option, especially for those looking for organic dairy and live active cultures. Some flavored varieties can be higher in added sugar, so I would compare labels and choose plain, lower-sugar or Greek versions when available.
- Oikos Greek Yogurt: A good higher-protein option, especially if you choose plain or lower-sugar varieties. Not every Oikos product is organic, and some lines use non-calorie sweeteners, so this is one where label-reading really matters.
- Yoplait Original: Easy to find and definitely tasty, but many flavors are higher in added sugar compared with plain or lower-sugar options. I would not call it my top everyday pick, but it can fit as an occasional yogurt choice if you enjoy it.
- Dannon Light + Fit: Low in calories and higher in protein in the Greek varieties, but typically sweetened with non-calorie sweeteners. This can be useful for some people, but I would not make it your only yogurt if you eat yogurt every day.
- Weight Watchers Yogurt Brands: These may be harder to find now, depending on your store and location. When choosing any “diet” yogurt, check the added sugar, protein and sweeteners rather than assuming the front of the package tells the whole story.
- Yoplait Light: I will admit, this type of yogurt has always nailed the dessert-like flavors. However, many light yogurts rely on added sweeteners and colors, so I would consider them more of an occasional choice than my first nutrition recommendation.
These six were the main yogurt varieties mentioned by The Healthy Apron Fans. Since brands change products all the time, I care less about brand loyalty and more about what the actual label says today.
Also, do not assume the most expensive yogurt is automatically the healthiest. Some store-brand plain Greek yogurts have excellent nutrition, simple ingredients and a price tag that does not make you question your life choices.
Bottom Line
A healthy yogurt does not need to be fancy, expensive or packed with every wellness buzzword on the container. Look for simple ingredients, live active cultures, a good amount of protein and limited added sugar.
Plain Greek yogurt with berries, nuts and a drizzle of honey is still one of my favorite options. But if the only way yogurt is happening for you is a lightly sweetened flavor you actually enjoy, I am not going to argue with that.
As with most foods, the goal is not perfection. It is choosing the better option most of the time and leaving a little room for the yogurt that tastes like key lime pie.
What is your favorite yogurt variety?
Leave Feedback: Was this article helpful?